THE A-Z MANUAL FOR BRINGING A CLOSURE TO THE SOUTH ASIAN “HAYATI VERSUS MAMATI” TRAUMA . Feb 6, 2013 By Ismail Ibrahim (This piece is based on a response given to a South African Mufti who ignorantly spoke out against anyone whom he perceived to be ‘Salafi’ towards the end of 2011) A. For those who are caught up in it, this issue of contention needs no introduction. The debate is South Asian in nature; its exportation is mainly down to migration . Ask an Arab or a Sub-Saharan African not caught up in this and they’ll express total ignorance over Hayati v. Mamati. B. What I propose is that we need to make a clean break from these useless, ambiguous, vague, non-universal terms of ‘Hayati v. Mamati’ , as they make no sense. One cannot hold a discussion, let alone a debate, if universal terms – let alone terms used by only in the polemics in one region of the Muslim world, like Hayati and Mamati – are not even defined. Yet it is a fact that both groups...
Institutional analysis on geopolitics, Islam, history, and the global secular order